Judge Orders Chicago Transit Funding Restored as Rail Projects Avoid Demobilization | Columbus Ohio Dump Trucks

RELATED

CTA Faces Imminent Rail Work Stoppages as $2.1B Transit Funding Freeze Heads to Court

At issue is roughly $2.1 billion in federal funding that has been frozen to support CTA's Red Line Extension and the Red and Purple Modernization Program. 

The Red Line Extension is a 5.5-mile expansion from 95th St. to 130th St. with four new stations, a rail yard and maintenance facilities, carrying a total project cost of approximately $3.75 billion with federal participation approaching $2 billion. 

The Red and Purple Modernization program, a multiyear rebuild of North Side track and stations, is nearing substantial completion but continues to rely on federal reimbursements for remaining work.

Court Finds Selective Enforcement

Judge Durkin issued the order following a hearing where federal attorneys acknowledged DOT had applied its October 2025 interim final rule retroactively only to grantees connected to Chicago and New York—out of hundreds of transit grants issued nationwide. 

The court found that targeting "indicates that the reviews for compliance with antidiscrimination laws are a pretextual basis" for purposes unrelated to the agency's stated rationale.

Building on that finding, DOT provided no further guidance between December 2025—when it informed CTA that its administrative review was complete and funding would resume upon certification—and March 2026, despite CTA having satisfied those conditions. 

Judge Durkin identified that silence as an independent basis for finding the agency's conduct likely arbitrary and capricious.

DOT did not respond to ENR's request for comment. 

The federal government has not publicly indicated whether it intends to seek a stay from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.

Jurisdiction and Merits

Map shows the preferred alignment for the Chicago Transit Authority’s Red Line Extension from 95th Street to 130th Street, including proposed station locations and rail yard, one of two projects affected by the federal funding dispute.

Map courtesy of Chicago Transit Authority

The government argued the dispute belonged in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims under the Tucker Act, but Judge Durkin rejected this, citing jurisdiction under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act, which allows federal district courts to review agency decisions withholding financial aid—the same authority DOT used to justify the initial freeze.

On the merits, which the government largely did not contest, the court found CTA likely to succeed on four grounds: that retroactive application of the rule was arbitrary and capricious; that DOT bypassed APA notice-and-comment and delayed-effectiveness requirements without identifying any emergency; that the agency failed to follow Title VI's mandatory procedural steps before suspending payments; and that DOT violated federal grant management regulations under 2 C.F.R. Part 200 by withholding reimbursements without identifying specific noncompliance or affording CTA an opportunity to respond. CTA submitted payment requests in early October 2025; more than five months later, the court found that DOT had not acted on them.

RELATED

USDOT Freezes $2.1B Already Awarded for Chicago Transit Projects

Contractors Stay on the Job

The ruling removes immediate risk of columbus oh dump truck work stoppage on both programs. Design-build contractor Walsh-VINCI Transit Community Partners, leading the $2.9-billion Red Line Extension, had already mobilized workers, project offices, field facilities and specialized columbus oh dump truck equipment along the corridor. 

CTA said hundreds of firms across both projects depend on federal reimbursements, with workforce continuity and construction sequencing tied directly to sustained payment flows.

The case joins similar disputes over New York's Second Avenue Subway Phase 2 and the Gateway Hudson Tunnel, collectively testing whether federal agencies can interrupt reimbursement streams on projects already funded and under construction.